The 8 Best Mexican Restaurants in Sheffield

Pellizco, nestled in Dyson Place, Sheffield, offers a delightful mix of traditional and modern Mexican dishes that keep diners coming back. Known for its flavorful tacos and varied salsa options, this spot is perfect for a casual meal or a fun night out with friends. Their margaritas—especially during happy hour—are a hit, and the outdoor courtyard is a lovely spot to enjoy your meal on sunny days. While portion sizes can sometimes be small, the vibrant atmosphere and friendly staff make for a great dining experience.

Sette Colli Restaurant in Hillsborough offers an inviting, cozy atmosphere paired with exceptional food. Known for its robust flavours and generous portions, dishes range from succulent prawns and juicy chicken to mouth-watering pasta and garlic bread with tomato and cheese. The relaxed setting makes it perfect for date nights, group gatherings, or casual meals. Friendly, attentive staff and reasonable prices, especially for the set menus, ensure a delightful dining experience that keeps guests coming back. It's a must-visit spot for authentic, high-quality Italian and Mexican cuisine.

El Paso is a lively and welcoming spot in Sheffield known for its delicious Mexican cuisine and vibrant atmosphere. The menu offers a wide range of flavorful dishes, from fajitas to nachos, paired with tasty cocktails. The staff, particularly Ciro, are exceptionally friendly and make dining here an entertaining experience with dancing, sombreros, and even a conga line. Perfect for special celebrations, El Paso ensures a fun and memorable time with great food and outstanding service.

Piña in Sheffield offers a fun, casual vibe with an industrial-style interior, making it a great spot for a laid-back meal or night out. Their menu boasts a selection of tasty tacos, including the popular beef birria, and unique sides like corn ribs. While a bit pricey, the food is flavorful and well-executed. The margaritas are a highlight, strong and delicious with a variety of options. With friendly staff and a welcoming atmosphere, Piña is an excellent choice for enjoying Mexican cuisine and cocktails with friends.

Dos Amigos offers a delightful mix of Mexican and Italian cuisine in a cozy and clean setting. Known for its freshly prepared, flavorful dishes like fajitas, enchiladas, and lasagne, Dos Amigos promises a memorable dining experience. The friendly staff and prompt service add to the welcoming atmosphere, making it perfect for celebrations or a casual night out. Reasonably priced with generous portions, it's a favourite among locals who appreciate good food and excellent service.

Burrito Picante in Sheffield offers a delightful Mexican dining experience with a variety of options like burritos, tacos, quesadillas, and naked burritos. Known for its fresh ingredients and generous portions, this cozy spot also features great customer service and a friendly atmosphere. The staff are particularly attentive to allergies and dietary preferences, ensuring a pleasant visit for everyone. Popular items include the Tinga Taco and pulled pork burrito, and their churros are a must-try. It's perfect for a quick, tasty, and affordable meal.

Amigos in Sheffield serves up delicious and generous portions of Mexican food with a variety of options to suit everyone's taste. The atmosphere is welcoming and family-friendly, with friendly staff always ready to assist. Though the place has a rustic charm, it's spacious and clean, perfect for large groups. It's a BYOB spot, so plan accordingly. While some might find the music a bit loud, the overall dining experience remains enjoyable with tasty nachos, burritos, and more, all at reasonable prices.

Barburrito in Sheffield offers a vibrant and casual dining experience with its flavorful, freshly made burritos. The wide selection of ingredients allows customers to customize their meals to their liking, ensuring a tasty bite every time. The atmosphere is welcoming, and the friendly staff are always ready to help, providing excellent service and valuable recommendations. Whether you're craving a hearty beef burrito or a lighter, veggie option, Barburrito caters to all tastes, making it a popular spot for a quick, satisfying meal.